Warmlid

Versus

Insulated panels vs glass conservatory roof: light or shade?

If daylight overhead matters more to you than anything, choose new solar control glass; if you want the room cool in July and quiet in a storm, choose panels. That is the short verdict on insulated panels vs glass conservatory roof. Today's coated glass roof units are far better than the ones fitted twenty years ago, reflecting a good part of the sun and holding heat at about 1.2 to 1.6 W/m²K. A 75 mm panel roof sits at about 0.43 and lets no direct sun through at all.

So this is not a contest between a good roof and a bad one. It is a choice between two good roofs that do different jobs.

Dark grey insulated panel lean-to roof

What modern roof glass can do

A current glass roof unit is two or three panes with a gas fill and thin metal oxide coatings. One coating keeps room heat in, another bounces back a share of the incoming sunshine. Tinted versions in blue, grey or bronze turn back more still. Many come with a self-cleaning outer layer that loosens grime under daylight so the next shower can carry it away, which works best on steeper pitches.

The result is a roof that is noticeably cooler than old clear glass and far warmer in winter. It keeps the view of clouds and stars, which is the reason most people built a conservatory in the first place. We think that is worth saying plainly before anyone compares prices.

Victorian glass roof conservatory on a stone house
A glass Victorian roof on a stone built house.

Where clear glass still struggles

Even the best solar control coating lets a share of the sun's energy through, because it also has to let light through. On a bright afternoon that share lands on the floor and the furniture and warms them. The glass walls already let in plenty; a glass roof adds the strongest sun of the day from directly above.

Our Comfort Calendar model has figures for the kind of double glazed roof fitted in the 1990s and 2000s, at about 2.8 W/m²K. That older glass gives 1,467 waking hours a year above 25°C, against 317 under panels. A new solar control roof would land somewhere between the two, usually much closer to the old glass than to the solid roof, since it still admits sun. See the overheating league table of 104 towns for how location changes it.

Hottest hour of the year, average
  • Glass roof (older units)50°C
  • Polycarbonate roof47°C
  • Panel roof34°C

Comfort Calendar model; glass here means a 1990s or 2000s double glazed roof

Winter warmth compared

Think of a U-value as a leak rate: watts lost per square metre, per degree the outside is colder than the room. Smaller numbers keep more warmth. New glass at about 1.4 loses roughly three times as much as a panel roof at 0.43. On a 15 m² roof with 19°C inside and freezing outside, that is about 400 watts through the glass against about 125 watts through the panels.

That gap is real, but the walls are the same either way, so it shrinks once you count the whole room. Our model puts the heater needed on a 0°C morning at 1.8 kW under the older glass and 1.1 kW under panels. A brand new glass roof would sit roughly halfway between the two. If your room feels cold right now, what to do about a cold conservatory explains the other leaks too.

Glass roof and panel roof side by side

Glass prices vary widely with the coating chosen. For panels, our conservatory roof price guide shows the starting figures for each size and shape.

New solar control glass compared with a 75 mm insulated panel roof
New solar control glass Insulated panel roof
Cost Usually similar to panels or higher, more for tints and self-cleaning From £3,000 for a small room
Winter warmth U about 1.2 to 1.6 U about 0.43
Summer heat Better than old glass, still sunny and warm overhead 317 too-warm waking hours a year in our model
Daylight Full sky view Light from the walls, plus any roof lights
Rain noise Quieter than plastic, a crisp tap Muffled by 75 mm of foam
Lifespan Sealed units often last 20 to 25 years before misting Aluminium skins, 10 year guarantee
Upkeep Needs washing, especially on low pitches Occasional rinse, gutters cleared

Glare, privacy and what you see from the sofa

Glass overhead means the sun can find your screen at almost any hour. Tinted units soften that, but a laptop by a south facing glass roof still fights a bright patch. Under panels, light arrives from the sides at eye level, the way it does in an ordinary room, so a television can live anywhere.

There is also the view upwards. Some people love lying on the sofa watching rain run across the glass. Others notice neighbours' bedroom windows looking down. Only you know which camp you are in.

BeforeGlass roofed conservatory with a rattan sofa before replacement
AfterGarden view from a conservatory with a panel roof
A glass roof room before, and the same garden view under a panel roof.

Our verdict, room by room

If you are torn, a halfway house exists: a panel roof with one or two glazed roof lights keeps a slice of sky while cutting most of the summer heat. When you are ready to see figures for your own room, book a free survey.

New solar control glass suits

  • North or east facing rooms that rarely bake
  • Garden rooms where the sky view is the point
  • Owners happy to wash the roof or pay someone to
  • Rooms shaded by tall trees or a neighbouring house

An insulated panel roof suits

  • South and west facing rooms that hit 40°C
  • Home offices and TV rooms troubled by glare
  • Rooms where rain noise drowns out talk
  • Anyone who wants the coolest roof per pound

Questions people ask

Is self-cleaning glass really self-cleaning?

It helps, but it needs daylight and rain to work and a decent pitch to shed water. On a shallow lean-to, or under trees, it still gets dirty and needs a wash.

Does tinted roof glass make the room dark?

Darker tints cut light along with heat, so the room feels dimmer on grey days. Lighter neutral coatings keep more light but turn back less of the sun.

Can panels go on a roof that is glass now?

Yes. The glass units come out, the glazing bars are checked, and the panels go on the same frame. Our photos include several rooms that had glass roofs before.

Which is heavier, glass or panels?

Double glazed roof units are heavy, so a frame that already carries glass is usually well suited to panels. We still check every frame at the survey.

Keep reading

Ready to stop guessing?

Answer a few quick questions about your conservatory and get a guide price on screen. A surveyor then measures up and fixes it in writing.